AI portfolio analysis means asking an AI assistant questions about your real holdings: what you own, how concentrated you are, what has gained or lost, and what a change would do. It works well when the AI can read your actual numbers through a connected tool, and badly when it has to guess from what you type into a chat box. Use it to find things worth a closer look, then check every number that matters before you act on it.
This guide covers what AI is good and bad at with money, how to keep your data safe, prompts that give useful answers, a worked example of checking an answer, and the mistakes people make most. It applies whether you invest in the US, the UK, Singapore, India, the UAE or anywhere else.
Two ways to use AI on a portfolio
1. Describe your portfolio to a general chatbot. You type "I have about 60% in an index fund, 20% in my employer's shares..." and ask a question. The AI only knows what you told it. If your description is out of date or rounded, so is the answer. It also cannot see prices, currencies or dates you left out.
2. Connect the AI to a tool that holds your data. The AI asks the tool for your holdings, values and transactions, then answers from those. This removes the guessing about your own numbers. It does not remove the other limits of AI, which are covered below.
In Agni Folio, the second option is Astra, the chat assistant inside the app. If you already use Claude, ChatGPT or another assistant that supports MCP (Model Context Protocol), you can connect your own AI to your Agni Folio account and it gets the same set of tools Astra uses.
Either way, the answer is only as good as the data behind it. If half your money is missing from the tracker, the AI will confidently analyse the other half. Getting everything into one place first is covered in how to track all your investments in one place.
What AI is good at with your money
- Summarising a messy picture. "What is my net worth, split by asset type, currency and platform?" is tedious by hand across ten accounts and quick for a connected assistant.
- Spotting concentration. A holding that grew well can quietly become a quarter of your money. Asking "what is my largest holding as a share of the total?" finds it in seconds.
- Ranking. Best and worst performers, positions that have gone nowhere for years, holdings with no price for weeks.
- Explaining terms. XIRR, cost basis, expense ratio, coast FIRE. AI is a patient explainer, as long as you check country-specific rules elsewhere.
- "What if" arithmetic on your own assumptions. "If I save 1,500 a month more and expect 6% a year, when do I reach my target?" The AI does the sums. The assumptions are still yours.
- Turning text into records. Paste rows from a broker email or a contract note and ask it to record the trades. Astra reads the rows and shows them to you as a list to confirm before anything is saved.
What AI is bad at
- Predicting markets. No model knows what a share will do next month. A confident forecast is a sign to stop reading, not a reason to trade.
- Current tax and legal rules for your country. Rules change every budget. A model may describe last year's rate, another country's rule, or a mix of both. Always confirm tax points on the official site (IRS, HMRC, IRAS, the Income Tax Department of India, the UAE Federal Tax Authority) or with an adviser.
- Live prices. A connected assistant reads the prices the tool last stored. In Agni Folio that is the latest refreshed price, not a live trading screen. Use your broker for the price you will actually trade at.
- Long arithmetic without a tool. Language models can add up 40 numbers wrongly while sounding sure. A connected assistant should get totals from the tool, not compute them in its head. Ask where a total came from.
- Your life. It does not know you are buying a home next year, that your job is shaky, or that you cannot sleep through a 30% fall unless you tell it.
- Admitting gaps. If data is missing, some assistants fill the gap with a plausible guess. Ask "what data did you not have?" as a habit.
Privacy: what to share and what never to share
Whatever AI you use, some things should never go into a chat:
- Passwords, PINs and one-time codes
- Full account, card or national ID numbers
- Crypto recovery phrases or private keys
- Exchange API keys that can trade or withdraw
- Scans of statements you have not cropped or redacted
Amounts, percentages, tickers, goals and timelines are fine. "60% shares, 30% bonds, 10% cash, retiring in 18 years" is enough for most questions and identifies nobody. Our free lesson Keep your financial data safe goes through this in detail.
How Astra handles your data
- Your data only. Astra's tools read the signed-in user's portfolio and nobody else's.
- An outside model writes the answer. Astra sends your question, plus the portfolio data its tools fetched, to an AI model run by an outside provider. Astra uses paid models only, not free ones, which keeps it away from free models whose terms may allow training on what you send. Treat it as you would any cloud service: do not type anything from the "never share" list above.
- Changes need your click. Astra can read freely, but anything that changes your records (adding a holding, editing a transaction, deleting an entry) is shown to you as a card first. Nothing changes until you press Confirm.
- It cannot trade. Astra changes your records in Agni Folio. It has no access to your broker or bank and cannot buy, sell or move real money.
- Everything is logged. Each tool Astra runs is written to an audit log.
If you connect your own AI through MCP
When you approve the connection, you choose the access: read only, or read and write. Start with read only. With write access, your AI app can make changes directly, so its own "allow this action?" prompt becomes your safety check. You can disconnect any AI app at any time from Settings, Connected AI, and later requests from it are refused.
Prompts that give useful answers
Good prompts are specific, ask for the numbers behind the answer, and say what currency you want. Copy these and adjust.
Overview
- "What is my total net worth in my display currency, split by asset type and by currency?"
- "How is my money split across brokers, banks and platforms?"
- "Looking at my actual holdings, what are the three things most worth my attention, and why? Show the numbers."
Concentration and risk
- "List my ten largest holdings with each one's share of my total."
- "How much of my net worth depends on one employer, one country or one currency?"
- "Which holdings have not had a price update recently?"
Performance
- "What are my five best and five worst holdings by gain or loss since purchase?"
- "What is my total invested, current value and unrealised gain?"
- "What is my crypto profit and loss by coin?" (needs your cost basis set; see true crypto profit and loss)
Planning
- "Based on my tracked data, how close am I to my FIRE number?"
- "If I invested 1,000 more a month at 6% a year, how many years earlier would I reach it?"
- "If I needed 10,000 next month, which holdings could I sell with the least disruption? Do not record anything."
Housekeeping
- "Are any of my holdings set up with the wrong type or currency?"
- "Add these trades:" followed by pasted rows from a contract note. Then check the list Astra shows you before confirming.
Worked example: checking an AI answer
Priya lives in Singapore and tracks everything in US dollars. Her portfolio:
| Holding | Value (USD) | Share of total |
|---|---|---|
| Global index fund | 95,000 | 38% |
| Employer shares | 45,000 | 18% |
| Bond fund | 40,000 | 16% |
| Cash deposits | 30,000 | 12% |
| Property fund (REIT) | 25,000 | 10% |
| Crypto | 15,000 | 6% |
| Total | 250,000 | 100% |
She asks: "How much of my portfolio is in equities?" The AI replies: "62%."
Her own sum of the index fund and employer shares is 95,000 + 45,000 = 140,000, which is 56% of 250,000. So where did 62% come from? She asks the follow-up that solves most of these puzzles: "Which holdings did you count, and what values did you use?" The AI lists the index fund, the employer shares and the crypto: 140,000 + 15,000 = 155,000, and 155,000 / 250,000 = 62%.
Neither number is wrong. They answer different questions. But if Priya had used 62% to decide how much to move into bonds, she would have moved money based on a definition she did not choose. The fix is to ask precisely: "equities, not counting crypto or REITs."
The same check catches a more serious error: adding up numbers in different currencies. Say she also holds SGD 80,000 in a savings account. Adding 250,000 and 80,000 to get "330,000" mixes dollars with Singapore dollars and means nothing. At an illustrative rate of 1 USD = 1.30 SGD, the savings are worth 80,000 / 1.30 = about USD 61,538, so her true total is about USD 311,538. A good connected tool converts every holding to one currency before adding. Astra's tools give it values already converted to your display currency and tell it to add only those, but it is still worth asking "what currency is this total in?"
Five checks before you act on an AI answer
- Ask for the inputs. "Which holdings and values did you use?" If it cannot say, do not rely on the answer.
- Compare the total with your dashboard. If the AI's net worth differs from the figure on your screen, something was missed or double counted.
- Check the currency and the date. Which currency is the total in, and how old are the prices?
- Ask the question a second way. "What share of my money is in my employer's shares?" and "How much would I lose if my employer's shares halved?" should agree. Here: 45,000 is 18% of 250,000, and half of it is 22,500, or 9% of the total.
- Verify rules at the source. For anything about tax, retirement accounts or legal limits, read the official page for your country. The AI's job was to point you there.
Common mistakes
- Treating the answer as advice. In most countries, personal investment advice is a regulated activity. An AI chat is not a licensed adviser and does not know your full situation.
- Analysing an incomplete portfolio. If the old workplace pension and the second bank account are not tracked, every percentage is wrong.
- Asking vague questions. "Am I diversified?" gets a vague answer. "What share of my total is in my three largest holdings?" gets a number.
- Pasting whole statements into a general chatbot. You hand over account numbers and addresses along with the figures. Crop and redact, or use a connected tool.
- Confirming changes without reading them. When Astra proposes adding 40 trades, read the list. Check dates, units and prices on a few rows at least.
- Trading on a forecast. If the answer includes "will rise" or "will fall", ignore that part.
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to give an AI my portfolio?
Sharing amounts, percentages and tickers is low risk. Sharing anything that grants access (passwords, codes, recovery phrases, trading API keys) or identifies accounts (full account numbers, ID numbers) is not. A connected tool with read-only access, an audit log and a way to revoke access is safer than pasting statements into a chat.
Can AI tell me which stocks or funds to buy?
It can explain options and show how a change would affect your allocation. It cannot know what will perform well, and it is not a licensed adviser. Use it to understand your position, then decide yourself or with a regulated professional.
Can Astra buy or sell for me?
No. Astra can only change your records in Agni Folio, and only after you confirm each change. It has no connection that can place trades or move money.
Should I use Astra or my own AI through MCP?
They use the same tools on your data. Astra needs no setup and asks you to confirm every change inside Agni Folio. Your own AI makes sense if you already pay for one, want to mix portfolio questions with other work in the same chat, or prefer that company's data terms. See how to connect your own AI.
Why does the AI's total differ from my dashboard?
Usually one of three things: it added amounts in different currencies, it left out holdings with no price, or it is answering a narrower question than you meant (one account, one family member, one asset type). Ask which holdings it counted.
Does the AI know my country's tax rules?
Only roughly, and possibly out of date. Use it to understand the idea and to prepare questions, then confirm the current rule on your tax authority's site or with an adviser.
Getting started
Put all your holdings in one place first, including the accounts you rarely look at. Then open Astra from the app menu and start with one question: "What are the three things in my portfolio most worth my attention, and why? Show the numbers." Check the answer with the five checks above. For more prompt ideas, see How to ask good money questions.